About Oral Histories
Background
It was primary election day in 2004 when Jo Ann Buller first told several neighbors her idea of compiling a history of our Philadelphia neighborhood, Society Hill, during its redevelopment in the 1950s and ’60s. Over the intervening years, the story had been told from the point of view of the city’s elected officials and civic leaders under whose direction redevelopment had taken place, and the project is considered by many to be one of the most successful urban renewal projects in the country. Jo Ann’s innovation was to tell the story from the perspective of people like ourselves, who had bought derelict houses in Society Hill to restore, or who had built new houses on vacant lots. There was some urgency because some people whose stories we wanted to record were getting on in years and others were moving away.
The project’s initial core group included Jane Eiman and Dorothy Stevens, in addition to Jo Ann Buller and Cynthia J. Eiseman; and while Jane dropped out early in the project, she continued to be supportive. After discussing the idea with several neighbors, we welcomed two to our group: Penelope Hartshorne Batcheler, an architect who had devoted her career to Independence National Historical Park and to historic preservation; and Karen D. Stevens, who had moved to the neighborhood in the 1990s. As the librarian and archivist at Independence National Historical Park, she too proved to be an invaluable resource. As the project drew to a close, we received expert help from Anne P. Meyers in preparing the manuscript.
While a few narrators opted to submit written reflections, we primarily decided to conduct oral history interviews. We gave the entire undertaking the working title of Project Philadelphia 19106, based upon the neighborhood zip code. We compiled a list of every neighbor we knew who had been involved in redevelopment. We then whittled down that list of more than 400 names to fewer than one hundred. We refer to the people we interviewed as “narrators.”
The Narrators
The narrators number 88 in all. We classified them into four groups.
Lifelong Residents (eleven narrators) were born in Society Hill in the 1920s or ‘30s or came there as very young children; most of them have lived in the neighborhood for the rest of their lives. They describe their houses, families, neighbors, schools, friends, playtime activities, places of worship, and other details of life in what was then called the Bloody Fifth Ward—for the behavior of people at polling places in that section of the city. The jobs they held, their leisure time activities, and the friendships they built over the years flesh out the picture of their lives. They also describe what it was like to learn of the changes that redevelopment would bring to their neighborhood and the impact it had on them, their neighbors, and their families. They do not hold back on their opinions of the Redevelopment Authority, the Mayor, or the civic leaders involved in redevelopment.
Redevelopers (59 narrators) came by the hundreds in the 1950s and ‘60s. We have divided this group into two sub-groups: Restorers, designated with R, restored old houses, and New Construction, designated with N, built new houses on vacant lots or bought new houses that had been built by developers. (Redevelopers with two letters had two houses.) Restorers tell how they found the house that best suited them, came up with the money for the down payment and renovations, and dealt with various city agencies to do the necessary work. They also discuss what they discovered as they cleaned out their houses and went to work on the renovations. Further, they describe meeting fellow new neighbors—newcomers like themselves—who were restoring old houses and were eager to make new friends and swap advice on restoration work. Relations with neighbors who were lifelong residents were often more awkward, at least initially; but many eventually developed into close and lasting friendships. Redevelopers who bought or built new houses explain why they chose that path. They tell stories about dealing with contractors, city agencies, and neighbors. They became involved in the neighborhood much as those who restored old houses.
We call the children of Redevelopers the Third Generation (nine people). They were born in the 1960s in Society Hill, often when their parents were rehabbing the family home. Some recall living in construction sites as young children. Much like the lifelong residents, but two generations later, they talk about their families, the houses they lived in, the schools they attended, their friends, where they played, and what they did for fun. When they entered middle school or high school, they often experienced a profound change: they left behind their familiar neighborhood schools, and some began attending private schools in the suburbs. There they met other people their own age who were suburbanites, and who themselves had some inaccurate notions about these city kids. Other Society Hill children went on to large public schools in other city neighborhoods and confronted their own set of biases and novel experiences. Some of them reflect on the influence that growing up in this special neighborhood has had on them as adults.
We became aware, unexpectedly, of the fourth group of narrators (nine people), Business People, while we were interviewing the first three groups. These are people who worked in or near the neighborhood (or whose parent or grandparent did) and provided goods or services to the community. Among them are two realtors, a third-generation owner of a hardware store, the daughter and granddaughter of a butcher, a public health nurse, the grandson of a bar and restaurant owner, owners of a liquid egg business, and an architect. While these business people may not have lived precisely in Society Hill, or their businesses may not have been located in the neighborhood, they were as much a part of the community as the residents due to the frequent contact they had with residents and the roles they played in their lives. They too offer worthwhile perspectives on the development and redevelopment of the neighborhood.
Not every narrator fits neatly into one or another category or meets all the criteria of a particular category. Still, all of the narrators had a connection with the neighborhood and give an account of their experiences that is worth sharing.
– Cynthia J. Eiseman